Best songs of 1942

8 May 2023

And the winners are?

As we go back more and more into vintage years there is a concern whether we would come across some familiar songs. There are indeed some undiscovered gems, but there are also many songs which have become immortal and have been part of us since the radio era. KL Saigal was a phenomenon. His starrer Bhakt Surdas ensures that all his songs including his duets and also some female solos are unforgettable. Basant of Bombay Talkies was a big musical based on a theatre-based story, and had many memorable songs and dances. If 1943 had Ram Rajya, 1942 had Bharat Milap with the same music director, Shankar Rao Vyas. Bharat Milap had some incredibly beautiful songs by Amirbai Karnataki. Jawab with music by Kamal Dasgupta had some famous songs by Kanan Devi. And there are many songs by Khemchand Prakash, Naushad and others scattered in the year which are either well-known or stick with you on the first hearing. On Naushad, I should mention that he gave music to three films in the year – Nai Duniya, Sharda and Station Master – of which the last two celebrated silver jubilees. That is some achievement for a young person of less than 23.

Broad statistics
Before I proceed further, let us take a look at the broad statistics of songs in the year, based on the Hindi Film Geet Kosh (HFGK). 915 songs in 95 films, i.e. an average of 9.63 songs per film matches with the trend in that era. This number per film has significantly come down because a film song’s purpose and the way a song is now made has completely changed. Of the 915 songs for which song titles are known, nothing is known with respect to 419 (43%) about their singers, lyricists or music directors. The “known unknowns” would increase progressively as we go further back. The last row showing the inter-se ratios between male solos to female solos to duets also follow the general trend: Female solos outnumbering male solos by some multiples, and the duets being somewhat more than male solos.

Macro snapshot of 1942

No. of films in 1942 98
Less number of films for which no details known (-) 3
Net number of films in which song titles known 95
No. of songs in which song titles known 915
Less number of songs of which singers not known (-) 419 (43%)
Net no. of songs of which singers known 496
Male solos 98 (19.76%)
Female solos 250 (50.40%)
Duets 130 (26.21%)
Chorus 18 (3.63%%)
Male solos: Female solos: Duets ratio 1: 2.55: 1.33

(Note: More song details are now available on the YouTube, but that would not be in a large number and the inter-se ratios would broadly remain the same.)

Fact file and Trivia
India was going through a churn with a landmark moment in the Independence Movement: Quit India. The world was going through its biggest turmoil in history as the World War II entered a critical phase with the Japanese strategic blunder of Pearl Harbour attack bringing the US directly in the war. Now it could end only one way – it indeed ended that way, three years down the line, but at a terrible cost to humanity.

This affected the film world, too, in a general way: shortages of raw stock, black-marketing leading to some unscrupulous, unfamiliar moneybags investing in the industry. But all the major studios – The New Theatres, Prabhat, Bombay Talkies, Sagar Movietone/National Studios – were going, too, through a turmoil because of their internal dissentions. The stalwarts of the New Theatres were leaving the studio due to ego clashes or for seeking greener pastures in Bombay. KL Saigal debuted in Bombay with Ranjit’s Bhakta Surdas; he would go back to Calcutta to complete My Sister (1944).

V Shantaram left Prabhat, and set up his own studio Rajkamal Kalamandir, which produced its first film Shakuntala in 1943. The film Roti in the year was a stinging criticism against  capitalism. This was the last film Mehboob Khan directed for an outside production house, National Studios (the successor entity of Sagar Movietone for which Mehboob Khan-Anil Biswas combo had a great run). He set up us his own Mehboob Khan Productions with the famous hammer & sickle logo and an invocation in the voice of Rafiq Ghaznavi, Muddai lakh bura chahe to kya hota hai, wohi hota hai jo manzoor-e-khuda hota hai, the famous lines of Agha Hashr Kashmiri. Roti had Begum Akhtar in an important role in the film. She sang six ghazals for the film of which four were finally removed. This film also marked the end of Mehboob Khan’s long association with his friend and the stalwart Anil Biswas. He would try different music directors from Rafiq Ghaznavi to others, until finally settling for Naushad. The readers might remember that the first film under Mehboob Khan’s banner was Najma in 1943.

Bombay Talkies faced internecine warfare with the demise of Himanshu Rai, in 1940. Between the factions led by Devika Rani-Amiya Chakravarty and that by Shashdhar Mukherji-Ashok Kumar-Gyan Mukherjee an uneasy truce prevailed for sometime with the two factions remaining under the same banner but producing films by different directors. Basant in the year was a musical blockbuster directed by Amiya Chakravarty. Pannalal Ghosh is credited as its music director, but Anil Biswas claimed that actually he was the music director and Panna Babu only gave orchestration and background music. His claim is now widely recognised. Anil Biswas could not lend his name officially as he was under contract with the National Studios. To complete the Bombay Talkies story, as we all know, immediately next year the other faction made a spectacularly successful film, Kismet (1943), directed by Gyan Mukherjee. But they were finding it increasingly difficult to remain under the same umbrella, and set up their own production house ‘Filmistan’.

Basant has the credit of a unique achievement. Baby Mumtaz, who would go on to become the Venus of India under the name Madhubala, debuted in a child role in the film playing the leading lady Mumtaz Shanti as a child. She also sang a child version of the song, Tumko mubarak ho unche mahal ye, humko mubarak hamari galiyan. Some sources mention that this version was sung by Parul Ghosh’s daughter Shanti Sudha Ghosh, which Baby Mumtaz lip-synched. Of course we know the iconic mature version by Parul Ghosh, picturised on the leading lady Mumtaz Shanti. I may mention that there was also another child song, Mere chhote se man mein chhoti si duniya re, picturised on Baby Mumtaz (Madhubala) as the child Mumtaz Shanti.

The year also saw the demise of Wadia Movietone. The property was purchased by V Shantaram where he set up his Rajkamal Kalamandir. The brothers JBH Wadia and Homi Wadia split with Homi establishing his new production house Basant Pictures. He later married the Wadia’s stunt queen the Fearless Nadia.

AR Kardar set up his own studios in the year. Kardar had directed Nai Duniya (1942) under an outside production house. This film had music by Naushad. But with Sharda in the same year, Naushad’s long association with Kardar Productions started on a fixed salary. By the 1950s, realising his market value Naushad broke apart from Kardar.

Debuts
The year was a cornucopia of some famous debuts. Suraiya debuted as a singer in the year with Boot karun main polish babu, boot karun main polish (Nai Duniya). Suraiya sang playback for other actors, such as the well-known Mehtab in some films; she would start her journey as a great actor-singer for herself for the first time a year later in Hamari Baat (1943), though she is also listed in the cast of Station Master (1942) lower down, and also sang some female duets and chorus. Hemant Kumar sang his first Hindi film song, Aankhon ki oat jo rahta tha, in Meenakshi with music by Pankaj Mullick. Ghulam Haider introduced Noorjehan with Khandan in the year, just as he had Shamshad Begum a year earlier in Khazanchi (1941) with some great songs. Noorjehan would go on to become the leading actor-singer until she migrated to Pakistan. Jagmohan Sursagar sang his first Hindi film song in Bhakta Kabir. Bharat Bushan debuted in a leading role with this film. Manna Dey debuted as a singer in Hindi films with the film Tamanna (Jaago usha aayi panchhi bole jaago), under the baton of his uncle KC Dey.

Prem Adib and Shobhna Samarth played their first roles as Ram and Sita in the film Bharat Milap. This film became a great hit, and established them as Ram and Sita in the public mind.

Vasant Desai’s first movie as an independent music director was Shobha in the year. C Ramchandra debuted as a music director with the film Sukhi Jeevan, under the name Ram Chitalkar. In his initial years he tried different variations of his name before finally settling on C Ramchandra. As a singer, he continued to be known as Chitalkar. Ninu Majumdar debuted as a music director with the film Black Out. The famous music director of several non-film songs, Kamal Dasgupta made a successful entry in Hindi films with Jawab.

The lyricist Qamar Jalalabadi debuted with Zamindar; he would go on to achieve great fame in collaboration with Husnlal-Bhagatram, OP Nayyar and several other music directors.

Now let me present my list of memorable songs, some of which are well-known, and some impressed me on the first hearing while researching this post.

MEMORABLE SONGS

Apna Paraya: Lyrics Pt. Indra, Music Anil Biswas
1. Gori kaahe khadi angana atariya mein aao – Anil Biswas and Maya Banerjee
2. Pardesi ghar aa ja – Rajkumari
Baadal: Lyrics Tanveer Naqvi; Music Mushtaq Hussain
3. Aao chalein us paar sajni – by Zahoor Raja & Amirbai Karnataki
Basant: Lyrics PL Santoshi; Music Pannalal Ghosh (Anil Biswas)
4. Tumko mubarak ho oonche mahal ye – Parul Ghosh/ Baby Mumtaz  (or Shanti Sudha Ghosh, Parul Ghosh’s daughter)
5. Balam dheere bol koi sun lega – Amirbai Karnataki and Arun Kumar
6. Mere chhote se man mein chhoti si duniya re – Parul Ghosh /Shanti Sudha Ghosh
7. Ek duniya basa le mere man duniya basa le – Parul Ghosh & Arun Kumar
8. Kaanta laago re saajanwa mose raah chali na jaye – Arun Kumar & Parul Ghosh
9. Hua kya qasoor jo humse ho door – Amirbai Karnataki
10. Aya basant sakhi viraha ka ant sakhi – Arun Kumar & Parul Ghosh
11. Gori mose Ganga ke paar milna – Arun Kumar & Parul Ghosh
12. Ummeed unse kya thi aur kar wo kya rahe hain – Parul Ghosh
Bhakta Surdas: Lyrics DN Madhok; Music Gyan Dutt
13. Madhukar! Shyam hamaare chor – KL Saigal
14. Jis jogi ka jog liya wo jogi base bides – Khursheed & KL Saigal
15. Chandni raat aur taare khile hon – Khursheed & KL Saigal
16. Madhur madhur ga re manwa – Khursheed
17. Panchhi baawra chaand se preet lagaaye – Khursheed
18. Rain gayi ab hua savera – KL Saigal
19. Sar pe kadam ki chhaiyaan muraliya baaj rahi – Rajkumari & KL Saigal
20. Nain heen ko raah dikha prabhu – KL Saigal
21. Nis din barsat nain hamaare – KL Saigal & Mohinder Saigal
22. Maiya mori main nahin maakhan khayo – KL Saigal
Bharat Milap: Lyrics several; Music Shankar Rao Vyas
23. Utho utho hey Bharat tumhare Ram abhi hain aate – GM Durrani (?) & chorus
24. Rani Kaushalya kahe lalna nahavavoji more lalna nahavavoji – Amirbai Karnataki (lyrics Pt. Anuj)
25. Ban chale Ram Raghuvir – GM Durrani (lyrics Pt. Indra)
26. Prabhuji pahle paaon pakhaarun, Prabhu phir Ganga paar utaarun – Male voice+Amirbai Karnataki
Chandni: Lyrics DN Madhok; Music Khemchand Prakash
27. Giridhari O Giridhari! Chhed muraliya pyari – Khursheed
28. Nindiya jhulave meri munni ko sulave – Khursheed
Chowringhee: Lyrics several; Music Kazi Nazrul Islam (and Hanuman Prasad Sharma)
29. Sara din chhat peeti haath hun dukhaai re – Anis Khatoon (lyrics & music Kazi Nazrul Islam)
Chudiyan: Lyrics several; Music SN Tripathi
30. Chudi laya nahin manihar main chudi bin na rahihaun – Amirbai Karnataki & SN Tripathi
31. Gehun ke khet mein jo ho more raja to deejo pukar – Rajkumari & Prem Adib
32. Maan jaao tohe saree Banaras ki la dun – Unkown (lyrics Ramesh Gupta)
33. Amua taley phir se aao sajaniyan phagun ki aayi bahaar – Rajkumari & Prem Adib
Dukh Sukh: Lyrics Wali Saheb; Music Khemchand Prakash
34. Mori atariya pe aa ja ho, o pardesi panchhi – Sitara & Mukesh
Fariyad: lyircs DN Madhok; Music Khemchand Prakash
35. Ae dil-e-beqaraar bol kaahe ko ashqbar hai – Shamim
Gharib: Lyrics several; Music Anil Biswas
36. Mujhko jeene ka bahana mil gaya – Surendra (lyrics Dr Safdar ‘Aah’)
37. Kabhi jalwe dikhaye jaate hain – Surendra (lyrics Dr Safdar ‘Aah’)
38. Muhabbat ki duniya hai sabse nirali – Surendra (Dr ‘Aah’)
39. Baadal chhaye humse kya – Surendra
Ghar Sansar: Lyrics Ehsan Rizvi; Music Shyam Babu Pathak
40. Jhoolun hindola Shyam sang main to jhoolun hindola – Miss Kajjan
Iqraar (aka Tyag): Music Khemchand Prakash
41. Aankhon mein pani kis liye, ye zindagani kis liye – Master Vitthal of Sholapur
Jawab: Music Kamal Dasgupta
42. Toofan Mail, Ye duniya Toofan Mail – Kanan Devi (lyrics Buddhi Chandra Agrawal ‘Madhur’)
43. Balaayein lun main us dil ko jo duniya ke liye ro de – PC Barua (lyrics Bekal)
44. Chhup na jana, Ae chand chhup na jana – Kanan Devi (Bekal)
45. Kuchh yaad rahe to sun kar ja, tu haan kar ja ya na kar ja – Kanan Devi (Bekal)
46. Door desh ka rahnewala, aaya des paraye – Kanan Devi & Asit Baran (Bekal)
47. Dulhaniya chhama chham chhama chham chali – Anima Dasgupta (Madhur)
Jungle Princess: Lyrics Pt. Indra; Music Madhavlal Damodar Master
48. Agar insan mein himmat ho to kya kar nahin sakta – Sardar Mansoor
Khaandan: Music Ghulam Haider
49. Chalo paniyan bharan ko chalein – Noorjehan & Shamshad Begum
50. Tu kaun si badli mein mere chand hai aa ja – Noorjehan
51. Mere liye jahan mein chain na qaraar hai – Noorjehan
Lajwanti aka Radio Singer: lyrics (?); Music Shyam Babu Pathak
52. Teri mahima aparampar, tu hai jag ka paalanhar – Ratan Bai
Lalaji: Lyrics several; Music Vasant Kumar
53. Nindiya khoye diyo nainan mein aye ke – Anil Biswas
54. Meenakshi: Lyrics Pt. Bhushan; Music Pankaj Mullick
55. Aankhon ki oat jo rahta tha, wah kaan ke andar aan basa – Hemant Kumar
56. Tu gaye ja tu gaye ja, koi tera geet sune na sune – KC Dey
57. Man moorakh kahna maan, dukh sukh mein bhed na jaan – KC Dey
58. Ab preet ki jeet manayein saajan – Hemant Kumar & Suprova Sarkar
Mehmaan: Lyrics DN Madhok; Music Khemchand Prakash
59. Aayi atariya pe sone, na sone diya – Shamim
Muqabala: Lyrics A Karim; Music Khan Mastana
60. Mujrim hun mohabbat ka jo chaahe saza de do – Khan Mastana
61. Piya nainon mein aan samaye – Rajni
Nai Duniya: Lyrics Tanveer Naqvi; Music Naushad
62. Boot karun main polish babu, boot karun main polish – Baby Suraiya
63. Dil loot liya ji dil loot liya – GM Durrani & Rajkumari
Roti: Lyrics several; Music Anil Biswas
64. Phir fasal-e-bahar aayi dil-e-deewana – Akhtari Bai (lyrics Dr Safdar ‘Aah’)
65. Char dinon ki jawani, matwale pi le pi le – Akhtari Bai (Dr ‘Aah’)
66. Meghraj aaye, meghraj aaye, barkha laye – Sitara, Anil Biswas & chorus (Wajahat Mirza)
67. Garibon par daya karke bada ahsan karte ho – Ashraf (Dr ‘Aah’)
68. Sajna saanjh bhayi, aan milo aan milo – Sitara Devi
69. Wo hans rahe hain, aah kiye ja raha hun main – Akhtari Bai (Arzoo Lakhnavi)
70. Rahne laga hai dil mein andhera tere bagair – Akhtari Bai (Behhzad Lakhanavi)
Saugandh: Lyrics Pt. Natwar; Music RC Boral
71. Ab aayi basant bahar ujade se is jeevan mein – Asit Baran
72. Sakhi tori chaturai sab jaan gayi – Vinay Goswami
Sharda: Lyrics DN Madhok; Music Naushad
73. Panchhi ja, peechhe raha hai bachpan mera – Suraiya
74. Ghir aayi badariya ghar aao – Nirmala Devi
Society: Lyrics Hasrat Lakhnavi; music Rafiq Ghaznavi
75. Dost hua hai dushman-e-jaani, haye mohabbat haye jawani – Rafiq Ghaznavi
Station Master: Lyrics several; Music Naushad
76. Chalo chalo ri sakhi madhuban mein – Rajkumari & Suraiya (PL Santoshi)
77. Arey raja bade jatan se seenchu tori phulwari re haan re – Rajkumari
78. Baras gayi ram badariya kari, bujhi na pyas hamari – GM Durrani & Rajkumari (PL Santoshi)
79. More pardesi sajan lagi hai tumse lagan – Rajkumari
Tamanna: Lyrics SK Kalla; Music KC Dey
80. Jago aayi usha, panchhi bole jago – Manna Dey
Uljhan: Lyricist Kailash Matwala; Music Ramchandra Pal
81. Samdhi to darzin ka yaar, lagan ke kapde bane – chorus
Zamindar: Lyrics several; Music Ghulam Haider
82. Duniya mein garibon ko aaram nahin milta – Shamshad Begum (Qamar Jalalabadi)
83. Ja ri sakhi mere pi ko suna de sawan ke din aye ghar aa ja – Shamshad Begum & Umrao Jan Begum
84. Mere devra ki hogi sagai re – Shamshad Begum (Behzad Lakhanvi)

Special songs

The meat of these year-wise reviews is the section ‘Special songs’ which give a unique flavour that can’t fit anywhere. Enjoy some ‘Special songs’ of the year. I may have to mention some more in category-wise wrap ups.

1. Nis din barsat nain hamaare by KL Saigal (& Mohinder Saigal) from Bhakta Surdas (1942), lyrics Surdas, music Gyan Dutt

You must be rubbing your eyes. I always knew this song as a Saigal solo. This was my favourite among iconic KL Saigal solos. Surely this has to figure in the main section of the best male solos in the year. But listen to the song carefully, someone calls Soordasji and sings the last line Soor Shyam bhatko mat dar dar, kholo man ke dwaare. This is clearly sung by another voice. A comment in the YT link mentions that this line is sung by Saigal’s younger brother Mohinder Saigal who also played the role of Shri Krishna in the film. It is sad that this film is no longer available.

2. Utho utho hey Bharat tumhaare Ram abhi hain aate by GM Durrani (?) & chorus from Bharat Milap (1942), lyrics (?),  Music Shankar Rao Vyas

A heart-warming scene of Bharat Milap from the Ramayan story. A most befitting song to the film’s title, but I did not find it mentioned in HFGK.

3. Ui ma.. Abhi chhoti hun baalam jawan hone de by Brijmala, Menhdi Raja, Rewashankar from Return of Toofan Mail (1942), lyrics Pandit Indra, music Gyan Dutt

We lament the decline in the quality of lyrics in today’s songs. This one with suggestive ‘Ui ma, ui ma..’ in the beginning followed by the pleading, I am yet tender, let me ripen to full youth, leaves nothing to imagination. The antaras, too, are equally direct: Mera joban uchhalta hai aane ko ab/ Meri aankhon mein chhayi hai naadaniyan. No double entendres here. You would have noticed this was composed by the same Gyan Dutt who gave us all the devotional and melodious songs in Bhakta Surdas.

4. Agar insan mein himmat ho to kya kar nahin sakta by Sardar Mansoor from Jungle Princess (1942), lyrics Pt. Indra, music Madhavlal Damodar Master

This was a film by Wadia Movietone; the name of the film and Nadia in the star cast means she has to be the Fearless Nadia (born Mary Evans in Australia). The reason why I am including it in ‘Special songs’ is that the song is very good; Madhavlal Damodar Master was a talented and famous music director of the early era. But when he fell on bad times, he used to make his living by performing puppetry, and small tricks with his hands in moving buses and trains in the large metropolis. Imagine his childlike delight when he was among the dignitaries on the dais at the release of one of the volumes of HFGK at Bombay. (Please see comment #15 in the comment box for more updated information on Madhavlal Damodar Master.)

5. Arey samdhi to darjin ka yaar lagan ke kapde bane (chorus) from Uljhan (1942), lyrics Kailash Matwala, music Ramchandra Pal

This song is culturally significant as it depicts the tradition of singing gaalis in weddings. We are familiar with the baraats going to the bride’s place, but some wedding rituals also require the bride’s side to visit the groom’s place. The familiar accepted etiquette is that the hosts show utmost courtesy to the guests, but in a strange reversal the women of the host family sing gaalis addressed to the visitors. The samdhi is a yaar of the wife of the tailor so his dress for the wedding does not require any expenditure. The samdhin, on the other hand, is involved with the goldsmith who has taken care of her jewellery. The gaalis go on in the same vein. Since the women are shielded by parda, the anonymity gave them the license to be as crude and vulgar as they could, little realising that they were cracking crude jokes against the women of the other family. Growing urbanisation, female literacy and intermixing has led to the demise of this rural tradition.

6. Sajna saanjh bhayi aan milo by Sitara Devi from Roti (1942), lyrics Dr Safdar ‘Aah’, music Anil Biswas

This ‘special’ song is important because it must be the first ‘Item Song’ in Hindi films. It has a skimpily dressed Sitara Devi, dancing seductively as she gets up yawning from a sleep or dream, and there is a shocked audience. This clip is short, but I remember in the full song there were also drooling men, completing all the parameters of an item song.

7. Meghraj aaye, meghraj aaye by Sitara Devi, Anil Biswas & chorus from Roti (1942), lyrics Wajahat Mirza

The most direct-hitting anti-capitalism movie, Roti, was made in a surreal style. The city-slick rich people Chandramohan and Begum Akhtar accidentally land in their biplane in this fictional land populated by Shekh Mukhtar, Sitara Devi and other forest dwellers. They live in a bliss sharing all their produce among themselves, not aware of what is private ownership or what is profit or loss. Here is a group song wishing for clouds and rains.

8. Mohan tum mohan by Kamla from Sewa (1942), lyrics JC Kapoor, music SN Tripathi

This song is special because it is so much like a song from the New Theatres/Calcutta fold. In my mind I was conditioned to differentiate the cultural styles of music from the two centres. This is a beautiful ‘new’ discovery.

9. Nindiya khoye diyo nainan mein aye ke by Anil Biswas from Lalaji (1942), lyrics Arzoo Lakhanvi, music Vasant Kumar

The regular followers of SOY are aware that Anil Biswas has sung about 45 songs. But in some of his early songs he also appeared in the movie and sang for himself. Lalaji is the only film in which has sung for another music director. He has sung two solos and a duet in the film.

10. Sara din chhat peeti hath hun dukhaai re by Anis Khatoon & chorus from Chowringhee (1942), lyrics and music Kazi Nazrul Islam

Chowringhee comprising Esplanade, Maidan and the central areas of Park Street, Camac Street etc. is the quintessential urban district of Calcutta, and also the metaphor for the urban chaos of the metropolis. There is a famous eponymous Bengali novel by Shankar on which a landmark movie starring Uttam Kumar has been made; as also the highly acclaimed 36 Chowringhee Lane made by Aparna Sen. But this song is unique for another reason. The legendary Bengali poet of post-Rabindranath Tagore era, Kazi Nazrul Islam has given music for the only Hindi film in his career in which he also wrote some songs. I hope our Bengali friends would enlighten us more on Kazi Nazrul Islam and on Nazrul Geeti. He was venerated on both sides of the eastern border. After independence, Bangladesh invited him there and accorded him the honour of National Poet. He passed away there a few years later in poor health. This song describes the toil of women construction workers. The hands of women are aching after laying and pounding the roof for the whole day.

And finally the SOY Award for the Best of 1942 goes to?

Now this review is presented before the music lovers for their comments, views and choice of:

The Best Male solos of 1942
The Best Female solos of 1942
The Best Duets of 1942
and,
The Best Music Director of 1942

Acknowledgements and Disclaimer
1. I have been greatly helped by Arunkumar Deshmukh who shared his notes generously with me.
2. Hindi Movies / Films Songs (hindi-movies-songs.com)
3. 1942a (hindi-films-songs.com)
4. Atul Song A Day
5. Hindi Film Geet Kosh
6. The song links have been embedded from the YouTube only for the listening pleasure of the music lovers. This blog claims no copyright over them, which vests with the respective owners.

{ 35 comments… read them below or add one }

1 neeruahaf May 8, 2023 at 1:05 pm

Thank you, AK ji. I was waiting for this post and getting just a wee bit apprehensive since April was already past:) As usual, a wonderful well-researched overview of the year.

Last year, I told you that you had given little time to select the male solo but this year I need absolutely no time. It is Nainheen ko raah dikhayo Prabhu by Saigal saab from Bhakt Surdas
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1RzhuKkRhXg

2 AK May 8, 2023 at 3:07 pm

Neeruahaf,
You are welcome. Thanks a lot for your appreciation. I could not agree with you more on male solo.

3 Mehfil Mein Meri May 8, 2023 at 11:05 pm

What an in-depth research!
Excellent overview of the year.

Best male solo for me is
– Madhukar shyam by K L saigal

Best female solo
Jointly as usual
– Pardesi ghar Aaja by Rajkumari
– Rehne Laga hai by Begum Akhtar
– Panchhi Bawra by Khursheed
– Mere Liye Jahan Mein by Noorjahan

I would also add that my favourites female solos from 1942 alao include, Panchhi Ja by suraiya and Mere Chhote se Man Mein by Parul Ghosh. I like ans love all these 6 songs equally making it difficult for me to choose just one.

Best music director
Jointly to Anil Biswas and Gyan Dutt

Best duet
Kanta Lago re Sajanwa

Wasn’t an easy task at all!

Anup
🙂

4 AK May 8, 2023 at 11:29 pm

Anup,
Thanks a lot for your appreciation.

Best male solo has to be by KL Saigal.
Female solos present difficult choice but I don’t find my favourite Amirbai Karnataki in your list.

Joint music directors: I can see your point about Anil Biswas and Gyan Dutt.

Best duet: There are many and, in my opinion superior to Kanta lago re saajanwa.

5 Mahesh May 9, 2023 at 12:33 am

AK ji,

Many Thanks for this in-depth analysis of 1942 in the annals of HFM.
Hindi Film Song by Ashok Da. Ranade provides another trivia that Film Society that became defunct in 1955 was launched in 42.

Dukh Sukh was the only film of Mukesh in 1942 in which he acted and sang two duets with Sitara. One is represented, the other being,

https://youtu.be/KnLN89Wteps

My choices,

KL Saigal,

Kanan Devi in Jawab for Toofan mail

I agree with Anup ji for the duo afa composers are concerned. I am tempted to add Khemchand Prakash for the sheer number of films he composed, but three is crowd.

Basant should be a strong contender for duets.

Thanks

6 AK May 9, 2023 at 6:27 am

Mahesh,
You are welcome. Thanks for posting the other duet of Mukesh and Sitara from Dukh Sukh.

KL Saigal is undisputed. Female solos and Duets pose difficult choices.

7 Arun kumar Deshmukh May 12, 2023 at 7:34 pm

AK ji,
Thanks for a post on musical scene of 1942. Your writings are always in depth and detailed and they give pleasure in reading. Your analytical capacity too is noteworthy.
My choices are….
Best male Solo- K.L.Saigal in film Bhakta Surdas, song ” Madhukar Shyam hamare chor”
Best female Solo- Kanan Devi in film Jawab, song-Toofan mail, ye duniya Toofan Mail ”
Best Duet- Kanan Devi and Asit Baran in film Jawab, ” Door desh ka rahnewala….
Best MD- Kamal Dasgupta
-AD

8 AK May 12, 2023 at 9:51 pm

Arunji,
Thanks a lot for your appreciation. You have been a big help with the facts about vintage years. On best male singer there seems to be no doubt. For others we have to take a look.

9 Gaddeswarup May 13, 2023 at 5:04 pm

That Saigal song was a big surprise, He had a brother who could sing a bit and we never heard of him. As I limp towards 82, there are still surprises in store.

10 AK May 13, 2023 at 7:29 pm

Gaddeswarupji,
How time flies, none of us are getting younger. Welcome back after a long time. Yes, I had heard of Saigal’s younger brother, but it was the first time I really noticed his voice in one of my favourite songs.

11 Gaddeswarup May 14, 2023 at 2:29 am

AKJi, I still browse the posts but Hindi is getting more difficult with age and am still preoccupied with mathematics. There was time when I used to walk off Radio Ceylon around 7:57am but Saigal grows on you.

12 S Joseph May 19, 2023 at 6:45 pm

A well written post that brings to life HFM particularly of the year 1942 and the details of some important happenings of the Hindi Film world then . Would have been the loser if I had not read this composition. True , a lot of movies as well as songs have been lost forever .

Apparently , life was normal in the film world then as so much happened in that year…98 movies , 916 songs recorded, so many debutants …,and all this despite happenings like WW 2 , Quit India movement, jailing of so many leaders , …

Selecting and listing the 84 songs is a great effort . Nice listening to the 10 special songs , most of which I heard for the first time .

13 AK May 19, 2023 at 9:58 pm

Mr S Joseph,
Thanks a lot for your appreciation. Now your choices for the best?

14 Ashok M Vaishnav May 25, 2023 at 4:22 pm

Every year from 1947 I have joined the series Best songs of year with a sense of trepidation, since my knowledge of, and natural aptitude for, the vintage era songs is very limited,
However, each year the journey has been rewarding too.
I am happy to join the series for the year 1942 with more trepidation as I read the overview article.
Thank you so much SoY and AKji for expanding my horizon of Hindi film songs.

15 Arunkumar Deshmukh May 26, 2023 at 9:24 pm

AK ji,
I just now saw what was written about MD-Madholal Master ,in song No. 4 above in this post. Just to clarify matters, lest readers may think otherwise about his last days, I am giving a part of my article on him.
Madholal was well to do, till the end. His only daughter was settled in US, where he had been to visit her twice. He lived with his wife in a self owned posh flat in Shivaji park, Dadar. He was murdered, when his wife was in hospital and he was alone in the house.
” Unable to cope up with the changed pattern of Music and public taste, he retired from this profession after his last film- Jungle ka Jawahir-52. After this he pursued his hobby of Puppet making and soon developed a flourishing business. Internationally well known, he was the only Indian member honoured by the International Puppetiers’ Organization. He was the Director of Indian Institute of Puppetry. Very few people know that it was his JOKER PUPPET which was used by Raj Kapoor in his ambitious film MERA NAAM JOKER-1970.
He was invited as a special guest for the release ceremony for the HFGK-Vol I, on 8-10-1988, after Harmandir ji meticulously made special efforts to locate him in Bombay. He was overwhelmed with this gesture. Madholal ji showed a Catalogue to Harmandir ji, in which Madholal ji had recorded information about all songs composed by him with details of every film that he did in his career. Harmandir ji was wonder struck with his systematic records. In the ceremony, senior artistes like Naushad, Sitara Devi, Rajkumari ji etc all touched his feet with respect. He regaled the audience with his humorous talk for an hour. He had spent 38 years before this in anonymity. It is very sad that his life ended in such a tragic way. ( His daughter from USA, informed us recently that the murderer was apprehended, after an year.)
-AD

16 AK May 26, 2023 at 11:14 pm

Arunji,
Thanks a lot for this up to date information on Madholal Damodar Master. My memory of him was the release ceremony of HFGK 1, where his childlike delight was lovable.

17 RaunakJoy June 26, 2023 at 4:37 pm

Impeccable research and analysis, as always on your part. The consistency that you have shown over the years is remarkable. Big Cheers for that!

1942 itself was quite an interesting year for Hindi cinema with its fair share of good, bad and indifferent films. Apna Ghar (the best film of the year by far), Ankh Michauli, Armaan, Basant, Bhakta Kabir, Bharat Milap, Chauranghee, Jawab, Kunwara Baap, Mahakavi Kalidas, Roti and Saugandh were some of the good pictures 0f 1942.

Musically too, the year had atleast three all time great albums in Gyan Dutt’s Bhakt Surdas, Anil Biswas’ Roti and Kamal Dasgupta’s Jawab. Basant too was a very fine soundtrack which just fell short of greatness. Outside of these, there were some other good albums too in the form of Bharat Milap & Armaan. Sursagar Himanghsu Dutt too made an impressive Hindi debut in Bhakta Kabir this year, which was also Bharat Bhushan’s debut movie.

Of course, the year had some musical lows too. For example, Ghulam Haider’s both 1942 releases in Khandaan and Zamindar, while being big hits, were not quite at par with the quality of his work in previous year’s Khazanchi. Similarly, RC Boral and Pankaj Mullick’s work in Saugandh & Meenakshi respectively, while boasting of few bonafide gems, didn’t quite live up to their earlier hallowed track record. Khemchand Prakash too while composing for nearly half a dozen pictures this year, had a rather mellow outing with no standout album to his credit this year. Some good songs here and there definitely. But nothing in the league of Tansen, Pardesi or Bharathari for him in 1942!!

18 RaunakJoy June 26, 2023 at 5:05 pm

Anyways, my choices for this year are as follows.. Starting with the ten male top solos in reverse order..

10.) Gyan Dutt- Unknown to many, Gyan Dutt was a very impressive singer too, with quite a few hits to his credit in both Hindi and Bangla as a vocalist. Here is a song in his voice- Tu Kaisa Hai Bhagwan from Dheeraj, which I believe, deserves a spot in top 10 of this year.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A_zOEo-4M8E

9.) Surendra- A top singing star of this era, this was Surendra’s high time with his mentor Anil Biswas. In the later’s Garib, there are atleast 4 solo Surendra songs, all of which are worth listening. But out of those, I choose Teri Yaad Mein, as I find it to be a lovely precursor to Anilda’s iconic Mukesh solo a few years later in Dil Jalta Hai!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nEWnhURmWX4

8.) Ashraf Khan- His recitative songs in Anilda’s Roti might seem to be easy to render, but on closer inspection. they are anything but that. The desired effect of censure, sarcasm and in-your face messaging that Ashraf is able to lend to these songs needs to be appreciated. From his three solos in the film, I choose Reham Na Khana for its hard-hitting lyrical relevance and rendering that still lives on to this day.

7.) Asit Baran- Underrated but always reliable, Asit Baran delivered one of his best solos under Boral’s baton in Ab Aayi Basant Bahar (Saugandh).

6.) Ranjit Roy- A multi-talented man, Ranjit Roy’s renditions in comedy songs must have acted as a source of inspiration for our beloved Kishoreda’s later comic musical masterpieces. Right from 1936’s Sunehra Sansar to this delectable Kamal Dasgupta ditty from Jawab, Ranjit Roy always charmed one and all.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rdqiR5Nhbm4

5.) Jagmohan – When one Sursagar meets another Sursagar in Himanghshu Dutt, magic is bound to happen. A very moving Bhajan from Dutt’s Hindi debut in Bhakt Kabir.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n7frfrMp2PY

4.) KC Dey- Mann Murakh Kehna Maan from Pankajda’s Meenakshi. Sheer magic of KC Dey at its very best!

3.) KL Saigal- Rain Gayi Ab Hua Savera- Bhakt Surdas. Needs no introduction!
2.) KL Saigal- Nainheen Ko Raha Dikha Prabhu. Saigal, Gyan Dutt, DN Madhok, Bhakt Surdas again!! No description is needed again!
1.) KC Dey- My choice for year’s best male solo is Tu Apna Geet Sunaye Ja by KCD from PM’S Meenakshi. Of all the male singers in this Saigal era, two in KC Dey and Pankaj Mullick were no less than Saigal in quality, if not popularity. Anyways, we aren’t doing any Binaca Geetmala here that we need to go by popularity. I know it’s probably an offbeat choice, but KC Dey’s emotive power for me is second to none. And as KC Dey himself sang- Koi Tera Geet Sune Na Suney, Tu Apna Raag Sunaye Jaa… Tu Apna Raag Sunaye Jaa.. And so for me, this is the year’s best male solo. 🙂 🙂

19 AK June 26, 2023 at 10:34 pm

Raunak Joy @17.
Thanks a lot for your generous words. You have brought raunak to this review by your comments!

I am impressed by your overview of the best films of 1942. I have seen only two, and the obvious ones: Roti and Basant. I can get myself to watch the third one: Bharat Milap, but I don’t want to enlarge the net further. Here I might have some prejudice. On the other hand I am quite excited about the Hollywood classics of the 30s and 40s.

It was interesting to note your fascination for Apna Ghar. I presume you must have seen the other films, too, in your list. Quite impressive. I do find Shanta Apte has sung very melodious songs in the film.

I agree with you on your survey of the great albums in the year. You are very lukewarm about Khandan. The general understanding is that this film was to Noorjehan what Khazanchi (1941) was to Shamshad Begum.

20 AK June 26, 2023 at 10:58 pm

Raunak Joy @18,
I for one didn’t know that Gyan Dutt also sang. Interesting song for a trivia.

Surendra’s Teri yaad mein wo maza aa raha hai is a great find. Raag Darbari makes it an exact precursor to Dil jalta hai to jalne de. Thanks for mentioning it. I had missed this song; I have included four other songs of Surendra in the film.

Ram naam mukh bol by Jagmohan is an excellent song. Thanks for mentioning it. I had not given much thought to looking up its songs. I am very happy to see KC Dey’s Man moorakh kahna maan from Meenakshi at the 4th place. It has long been my great favourite. I entirely agree with your observation about the Great Trinity of singers of the New Theatres. I have often expressed similar views. However, your top choice for his Tu apna raag sunaye ja as quite unconventional, as you yourself seem to have realised.

Thanks a lot again for your very insightful comments.

21 RaunakJoy June 27, 2023 at 4:22 am

My Choice for Female top 10 in reverse order again…

Special Mention: Panchhi Jaa (Suraiya)- As they say in English, the morning shows the day. And the same held true for Suraiya too in this Naushad ditty.

10.) Sajna Saanjh Bhaiyi (Sitara Devi- Roti)- A very intriguing, slow burning dance number by Anilda!
9.) Pardesi Ghar Aaja ( Rajkumari- Apna Paraya)- The ever underrated Rajkumari seldom failed to deliver. And this Anilda beauty is one of her best.
8.) Roti –Begum Akhtar- Six solos, out of which atleast 4 are absolutely stunning. It was difficult to pick one, but my vote goes for Woh Hans Rahe Hai Aur Main Aah Kiye Ja Raha Hun.
7.) Mere Chhote se Mann Mein- Parul Ghosh (Basant)- A complete family affair where Parul Ghosh comes out triumphant.
6.) Madhur Madhur- Khursheed (Bhakt Surdas)- Panchi Bawra might be more famous, but this is no less a song from the same film!
5.) Raat Suhani Re- Shamim (Armaan)- Although not as great a singer as some of her other contemporaries were, Shamim was nonetheless a pretty competent crooner. In this unusual moonlight serenade of a composition set to a sort of rowing boat rhythm, Gyan Dutt uses a repeat Mukhda structure with no Antara using two delightful variations in the two starting lines of each Mukhda verse to devastating effect. Its like a short story well told in a musical format, and Shamim does justice to this experiment of Gyan Babu & Kidar Sharma.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GjXATvpxmhI

4.) Toofan mail ( Kanan Devi- Jawab)- The verve of Kanan Bala’s singing had few peers, back then or even now.
3.) Aye Chand Chupp Na Jana (Kanan Devi -Jawab)- The Kanan- Kamal Dasgupta show continues!!
2.) Panchhi Bawra (Khursheed- Bhakt Surdas)- In a soundtrack filled with Saigal beauties, Gyan Dutt reserved his best for Khursheed in this number, which in all probability is Khursheed’s ticket to singing immortality for all eons to come.
1.) Kuch Yaad Rahe toh (Kanan Devi- Jawab). This might sound like a Jawab overdose going on here, but such was the impact and class of Kanan-Dasgupta duo on display in Jawab that one couldn’t help but marvel at each of the three lovelies (each of different type too!) that the combination came up with in the film. This is my choice for the female solo of the year, though if non-film numbers would have been considered, I would have happily gone for Juthika Roy at number 1 spot. This after all was the year of her Chupke Se Bol Re Maina , which incidentally also happens to be a Kamal Dasgupta composition. But since, we are strictly restricting ourselves to film songs, this Kanan song is the tops of the year for me.

22 RaunakJ June 27, 2023 at 6:03 am

My choice for the top 10 duets in reverse order again-

Special Mention: Meghraj (Roti)- There have been many songs in Hindi cinema revolving around the theme of welcoming rains (so apt as just yesterday, monsoon finally arrived at my city of residence!). But none in my opinion have been able to capture the ethnic forest tribal beauty of it, in the way this number does. It just seems that somehow Anilda was able to give a melodious interpretation to even the croaking of frogs in the rain in this song. The rhythm of the song actually makes me feel as if even forest frogs were for once, merrily singing in the wake of the upcoming monsoon, and not just croaking!

10.) Prabhuji Pahle Paon (Bharat Milap)- There is no vintage-era year musically which can be complete without Amirbai’s magical vocals appearing in the top ten lists of the year. But even without Amirbai’s vocal virtuosity at display here, this Shankarrao Vyas number is a fine, fine number, which thoroughly deserves a spot here.
9.) Haay Dil Haay Dil ( Anil Biswas, Amar & Chorus- Vijay)- Anilda does a Boral here and presents a lengthy charming prelude, which incidentally reminded me of one of Ennio Morricone’s famous title scores. Even otherwise, this all male lament cum part spoof number has a delectable tune- so typical of its creator.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aUqDez4fk_8

8.) Paani Ke Raaja (Shanta Apte & co)- Composer HC Bali, more known in the history books for his role in helping both Kl Saigal & Lata Mangeshkar in their very initial days as struggling singers, was a rather underrated music director. Here is a folkish fisherman duet that he composed for Debaki Bose’s Apna Ghar, which I find to be absolutely delightful. A number which reminded me of later day Annasaheb’s boatmen song Katwa ke Naiya from Nadiya Ke Paar, this song, was in all probability sung by HC Bali himself, along with the ever charming vocals of Shanta Apte to give him good company.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TKcbuC6IeBQ

7.) Badnaam Na Ho Jana (Surendra- Husn Banu- Jawani)- Anilda’s spellbinding magic, which through the vocals of Surendra and Husn Banu, enraptures one and all.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TbMR7qePMXE

6.) Gori Mose Ganga Ke (Basant)- This is a typical UP folk style song, composed much before Rattan, in the year’s biggest hit- the Golden Jubilee Blockbuster Basant. The orchestration by Panna Babu, in particular, is noteworthy here.
5.) Ab Der Na Kar ( Sitara Devi- Mukesh- Dukh Sukh)- The only true great number composed by Khemchand Prakash this year, featuring the vocals of then-future giant in Mukesh.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KnLN89Wteps

4.) Tumko Mubarak Ho (Basant)- The film version has a male voice (possibly that of Suresh) to accompany that of Parul Ghosh, which is why I am considering this song as a duet. But duet or no duet, this is one of the best song of 1942 without an inch of a doubt.
3.) Jhooli Bhar Sitaren ( Bhakt Surdas)- When the two giants of that era in Saigal and Khursheed meet for the first time, magic was bound to happen. And it happened!
2.) Sar Par Kadamb Ki ( Bhakt Surdas)- This is one hell of a charming number. It is not easy to outdo a Saigal- Khursheed duet, but Rajkumari, under the baton of the unsung genius Gyan Dutt, did the unthinkable with the matchless Saigal in toe. Indeed, years later, the prelude of this number served as an inspiration for the prelude of a famous Govinda song.
1.) Duur Des Ka Rehnewala (Jawab)- For me the best duet of the year. Kamal Dasgupta’s composition is highly imaginative- and does full justice to the lyrics of this story-in-a-song number. Simply lovely!!

P.S: As an aside, I am not sure if this Jawab duet featured vocals of Asit Baran. Asit Baran, was then contracted to New Theatres, and this was a MP Films production. So, I am not sure if this was indeed Asit Baran who sang it alongwith Kanan Bala. Could it be Kamal Dasgupta himself doing the singing honours here? I am just plain curious…..

23 AK June 27, 2023 at 10:13 am

Raunak Joy @21,
Thanks a lot for your detailed comments and your choice of the ten best female solos of 1942. It is another masterpiece from you. However, I noticed the omission of Noorjehan. It was not a surprise as it is consistent with your views about the music of the film Khandan. I also notice the omission of Amirbai Karnataki and the film Bharat Milap. I realise tastes differ and one can’t include everything.

I am happy that all the ten songs of your list were noticed by me and figure in the main list of MEMORABLE SONGS. One of them, Sajna saanjh bhayi by Sitara Devi from Roti, I have included as a Special Song in this post as one of the earliest ‘Item Songs’. Wo hans rahe hain, aah kiye ja raha hun main is a lovely song. Begum Akhtar had sung an iconic ghazal in her early career, Deewana banana hai to deewana bana de. I find many songs on this stock tune. For example, her Rahne laga hai dil mein andhera tere bagair also follows the same tune. There are some other early female ghazals/songs too, some in different voices, based on this stock tune.

24 AK June 27, 2023 at 10:35 am

Raunak Joy @22,
Thanks a lot for the list of your choice for the best duets of 1942. I find I had missed quite a few in my list of MEMORABLE SONGS. I would like to especially thank you for the addition of Haye dil by Anil Biswas, Amar and chorus (Vijay). Your observation about the log prelude is very apt, but RC Boral’s orchestration was very different and was integral to the enjoyment of the song. I liked your glowing words about Amirbai Karnataki.

I also noticed an unusual Jholi bhar taare la de re, and omission of Jis jogi ka jog liya ho and Panchhi bawra from Bhakta Surdas.

Thanks a lot again for your very enlightening comments.

25 RaunakJ June 27, 2023 at 3:41 pm

Overall, my choices for the year as follows:-

1.) Male singer of the year- KL Saigal. For his excellence in both solos and duets, even though, as mentioned above, my favorite male solo performance of the year remains Tu Gaaye Jaa by KC Dey.
2.) Female singer of the year- Kanan Devi. Again for her combined excellence in both solos and duets.
3.) Album of the year- Jawab by Kamal Dasgupta
4.) Best MD of the year- Gyan Dutt & Anil Biswas jointly, for their versatile showing throughout the year. Both of them were as prolific as KP was in this year, but unlike KP, both had a much better output this year qualitatively. New theatres old timer Pratap Mukherjee too was prolific with 4-5 releases to his credit, but barring some delectable songs in his Dillagi, didn’t find his other work to be particularly memorable. HC Bali, too had multiple releases to his credit, and came up with some delightful numbers in Apna Ghar. But overall, Gyan D & Anil B stood head and shoulders above everyone else. Of course, if language and film music barriers weren’t there, Kamal Dasgupta would have come out at tops, for his entire output of Hindi & Bangla Film & Non-film songs had no peer that year across the country. But since we are focusing on music of Hindustani films only, GD & AB are undisputed choices for me for MD of the year.
5.) Lyrics of the year- This one was tricky as I found Safdar Aah’s lyrics in Roti to be really hard-hitting, DN Madhok’s lyrics in Panchi Bawra to be enchanting, and PL Santoshi’s work in Basant to be sweetly effective without making much ado about itself. Yet, finally I went for Pt. Madhur as the lyricist of the year for his Toofan Mail, simply for the reason that he came up with lines which worked at multiple levels. At one level, it could be seen as a song for children, and yet espoused philosophical leanings of a timeless quality for all adults. At the same time, the romanticism in the song is hard to miss. So for being able to achieve this combined effect operating at multiple levels, my choice for lyrics of the year is Pt. Madhur’s Toofan Mail.

26 AK June 27, 2023 at 9:37 pm

Raunak Joy,
Thanks a lot for your summing up. Your reasonings are very clear.

27 RaunakJ June 28, 2023 at 1:50 pm

AKji @19

Your excitement about the Hollywood classics of 30s & 40s is understandable. In general, our films of that period weren’t as good as theirs in that period. But there were certain exceptions. Our first 4 great directors in V. Shantaram, Debaki Bose, PC Barua and Nitin Bose, made some very very fine pictures- some of which were truly of international standards. Outside of them, there were certain selected pictures of filmmakers like Kidar Sharma, Phani Majumdar, S. Mukerji, Franz Osten, Himanshu Rai, Gyan Mukerji, Amiya Chakravarty, AR Kardar, Mehboob Khan, Kishore Sahu, Sarvottam Badami etc., which were memorable too. But in all fairness, they lacked the consistency of Shantaram, Debaki, Nitin or Barua; or of later day behemoths like Bimal Roy, Satyajit Ray, Ritwick Ghatak, Tapan Sinha, or even Satyen Bose or Raj Kapoor. Unfortunately, a big chunk of our great pictures from 30s and 40s are lost to neglect and apathy- including outright great films like Seeta, Puran Bhagat, Chitralekha, Pagal and Manzil.

No, I haven’t seen all the pictures that I have mentioned here. Have seen around 6-7 of these, the rest being untraceable as of now.

My list of best pictures comes from a combined efforts of self- viewing and in-depth research of articles, reviews, award functions and writings on cinema from that time and afterwards. The films that I have mentioned here are those films which in general received a favorable response from the audiences, though certain varying opinions did exist. For example, Both Roti and Jawab were thrashed by FilmIndia, but otherwise enjoyed a good response critically.

The one picture that enjoyed unanimous acclaim though was Debaki Bose’s Apna Ghar/Apule Ghar. The praise that it received was equal to what such cult films like Puran Bhagat, Devdas, Sant Tukaram, Adhikar, Vidyapati, Admi, Aurat, Ramshastri, Udayer Pathey, Neecha Nagar, Kalpana, Do Bigha Zameen, Pather Panchali or Meghe Dhaka Tara received in their respective year of release. It is hard to argue with such undivided praise.

That said, I haven’t seen Apna Ghar. It’s not available at the moment. But I have read the film’s story and all in great detail, and even while reading that, I was moved and could clearly see that it was head and shoulders above every other picture that year, which is why it got such praise from all quarters. Otherwise also, from what I have seen of Debaki Babu’s pictures like Vidyapati, Chandidas, Sapurey, Nartaki, Kavi, Bhagaban Shri Krishna Chaitanya, Ratnadeep, Sagar Sangamey & Arghya, he was a fabulous filmmaker. There is a reason why he became the first Indian filmmaker to get international recognition and why after Satyajit Ray & Mrinal Sen, within the country he remains the most awarded filmmaker.

28 RaunakJ June 28, 2023 at 2:41 pm

Akji@17

Yes, you are right about me being lukewarm about Khandaan and its music. While it’s true that it did shot Nurjehan into stardom the way Khazanchi had done for Shamshad Begum, I find its music to be lacking the freshness, verve, exuberance and innovation of Khazanchi’s score. The tunes are trite and tired in my opinion, with the exception of Tu Kaunsi Badli Mein- which I would have included in my list, hadn’t it been a blatant lift from a Marathi song. It’s for the same reason, I didn’t include Anilda’s Chaar Dinon from Roti, which took heavy inspiration from Nurjahan’s Gul-e-Bakavali number, composed by GH !

Khandaan, in my humble view, emerged as a big hit, due to the unprecedented publicity that preceded its release – and for the fact that it had a rather nice and original story (unlike Khazanchi which was a Holly rip-off) by Imtiaz Ali Tej of Anarkali fame.

29 RaunakJ June 28, 2023 at 2:45 pm

Akji @20

Thanks for your appreciation of Surendra’s Teri Yaad and Jagmohan’s Raam Naam. And I completely agree with you about the greatness of Kc Dey’s Mann Murakh number. It is simply a fabulous song.

And yes, there is little doubting the class of the holy trinity of New theatres singers!!

30 RaunakJ June 28, 2023 at 2:52 pm

Akji @23

Yes, you are totally spot on about Rehna Laga Hai being a stock tune from Begum Akhtar’s marvelous repertoire, which is the reason why I preferred Wo Hans Rahe over it.

Yes, I noticed that you had included Sitara Devi’s Roti song in the special song category. It is a thoroughly well deserved inclusion. And yes, I think, barring Shamim’s song from Armaan, all other songs were included in your list of memorable songs. 🙂 🙂 I guess, good music always unites more than it divides. 🙂 🙂

31 RaunakJ June 28, 2023 at 3:03 pm

Akji @24

No, Sir. I think you do a fantabulous job of covering the entire year in a very comprehensive manner. Given the sheer number of songs released in a year, it is not humanely possible for a single person to cover them all. Some omissions here and there are bound to happen. And it’s here that readers like us need to step in and complete the remaining jigsaw puzzle, so as to be able to come up with as wholesome a picture as it possible for the music of the year in question.

Yes, RC Boral’s prelude arrangement style was very different. But what I basically meant was this it was quite unusual for Anilda to do big preludes as he had done here. One did find GD and KP do so in their distinct and inimitable styles often. But with Anilda, this was rather a less frequent occurrence.

I did include Panchi Bawra among the female solos. I guess, you meant Chandni Raten Aur Tare Khilen Ho in its place? Both Chandni Raten aur Jis Jogi Ka numbers were in my reckoning. But don’t know, for some reasons even unknown to me, Jhooli Bhar appeals to me more. I guess, music, just like all other things, sometimes gets too subjective! 🙂 🙂

32 RaunakJ June 28, 2023 at 3:05 pm

AKji @26

The pleasure is all mine, Sir. 🙂 🙂 🙂 🙂

33 AK June 28, 2023 at 7:53 pm

Raunak Joy @27,
I have to carry further my point about the movies from the two streams. I have seen a good number of early Hindi classics, as also and more of Hollywood classics. Some differences you can’t miss and leaves you underwhelmed by our cinema.

Production quality: Print quality: We are very poor in preservation and restoration. It is impossible to get a good quality watchable print of 30s movies; contrast this with Gone With The Wind; Bringing Up Baby; Stagecoach.. I had to make efforts to watch Street Singer; Vidyapati. I find many cult movies of 70s, 80s too unavailable. When was the last you saw Rekha’s Umrao Jan or Prakash Jha’s Hip Hip Hurray.

Stilted dialogue delivery, especially of female actors: That really bugged me. Male dialogue delivery started smoothening soon; female dialogue delivery continued to be very artificial and jarring till the 40s. Talking of dialogues, I was taken aback by KL Saigal writing in the ill-fated letter – मैं अपने वालदैन की उदूलहुक्मी नहीं कर सकता (Even if the New Thetres regarded that kind of language appropriate, I thought the word should have been ‘hukm-udooli’). And when he meets with Jamuna (Paro), she retorts, Kya sirf tumhare waldain waldain hain, mere waldain kuchh bhi nahin? I had to scratch my head what was going on. Why not simple mata-pita which is appropriate to the Bengal’s milieu, and understood widely.

Script, acting, direction, editing: I found their product much more sophisticated in all departments.

In adaptations we are captive of our tropes. Dial M For Murder has been remade as Aitbar. Hitchcock ends as the detectives clamber up the stairs and find the culprit searching the door keys. Aitbar’s climax starts from that point, as Raj Babbar flees from the cops, there is a chase scene on the road and shootout.

I should add that that culture is totally alien to me, but there was a sense of watching good cinema, and it also showed the American society of the period.

34 Ashok Kumar Tyagi July 30, 2023 at 1:34 pm

AK ji,
As brought out by you and esteemed readers, 1942 was a year which had very good output of Film songs. The power struggle within studios and production house and outcomes/break-ups was intriguing — you have summarised it all in this post.
Nice to learn about the debuts of C Ramchandra and Vasant Desai (as independent MD).
Thanks.

35 AK July 31, 2023 at 3:35 pm

Tyagi ji,
Thanks a lot for your compliments. Every vintage year had some unique features about it. A lot of it is unknown. This series is a discovery trip for most of us.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: